Somebody has to start
shouting
Adam Keller
September 27. Evening. Here we are
again standing outside the Defence Ministry and protesting the army's deadly
actions in Gaza.
In fact, we could have demonstrated nearly every
other day, because every day brings its own ration of nasty news from
Gaza. And it had become markedly worse since Ehud Barak became Israeli Labour
Party leader, and Defence Minister, and with considerable energy is establishing
his credentials as the toughest of hawks.
Hardly a week passes without Barak making yet
another threat of "a major military operation into the Gaza Strip". Meanwhile,
he is authorizing daily "minor incursions" into the Strip, with an increasing
death toll. And also meanwhile, the economic siege and blockade of the Gaza
Strip becomes ever more tight.
The brilliant idea of cutting off the supply of
water and electricity to the Gaza Strip's 1,500,000 poverty-stricken
inhabitants brought on a sharp protest from UN Secretary General Ban, and a more
muted one from the US-led diplomatic "Quartet".
So, the government (so far?) did not cut off the
water and electricity. But they did make a legally binding legal declaration
that "Gaza is a Hostile Zone". This had the practical effect of making Bank
Hapoalim, Israel's largest, cut off all contacts with the Palestinian banks in
Gaza, with devastating results (among other things, making it impossible to
transfer money to those Gazans who still get some support from their former
bosses). Sherri Arison, multi-millionaire owner of the bank and an eager devotee
of "New Age" mysticism, has just a short time ago spent a lot of money on
an advertising campaign on the theme that "Peace Begins Inside
Yourself"...)
For those who want to, it is not difficult to know
what is happening in Gaza. Plenty of detailed of reports are available online.
But very little gets to the Israeli public by the commonly used media outlets.
(With a few honourable exceptions, such as the Channel 10 TV News, which
featured items on critically ill patients desperately waiting for permission to
get treatment in Israel, and on the new wing of Gaza's Shifa Hospital whose
construction was stopped since building materials are not allowed in through the
border passes).
Anyway, most Israelis have little sympathy for
Gazans, even if and when happening to hear of their plight. Since Sharon's
"Disengagement", official Israel has taken a pose of injured innocence,
massively disseminated by politicians and columnists and editorial writers and
taken up implicitly by most of the public: Israel has withdrawn from the strip
and dismantled its settlements, and the perfidious Palestinians responded
with the shooting of Qassam missiles. Therefore, "they brought it upon
themselves". Full stop.
Complicating factors are hardly ever mentioned,
such as the direct casual relations between the killing of Palestinians (some
700 in the past year, according to the recent proud boasting of PM Olmert) and
the retaliatory shooting of missiles (which cause destruction and panic but
only rarely kill).
Everybody who listens to Israeli news broadcasts
would unavoidably know of the anguish of the inhabitants of Sderot, especially
the town's children - who never know a moment of true rest, ever ready to rush
to shelter when the dreaded alarm sounds.
This never-ending anxiety in Sderot is all
too real, even if there are very few actual casualties. Yet the same media which
covers it in heart-rending full-page articles makes hardly any mention of
Palestinian children, who live in at least as much fear and who stand a far
greater risk of being blown to bits. The 16-year old boy crushed last week under
the threads of an Israeli bulldozer, which was engaged in "removing" orchards
which "may give cover to Quassam-shooting squads", got a bare laconic remark
from the army - "unfortunate collateral damage, he should not have been
there".
On the eve of the Jewish New Year, two weeks ago,
there was a surprise from Ismail Haniyeh - Gaza-based Hamas leader and
Prime Minister of one of the two rival Palestinian governments. Through
international mediators, Haniyeh proposed to discuss with the Olmert
Government the instituting of an immediate and bilateral ceasefire, and offered
to impose such a ceasefire on the smaller groups such as the Islamic Jihad
(which do most of the shooting).
Haniyeh's offer was not so much rejected as brushed
aside. Indeed, there was an immediate, noticeable notching up of both the
military offensive on the ground and the economic offensive through the banking
boardrooms (simultaneously with the continuing talks with Abu Mazen and his
team).
At least, the group of mainstream dovish writers
headed by Amos Oz and A.B. Yehoshua was aroused to action, prominently
publishing a call for an immediate ceasefire with Hamas.
And so we come to this day, Thursday, September 27,
at noon, in the lazy midst of the Sukkot Holiday, when some of us were
tempted to put off the radio and cut ourselves off from the world for a bit. But
the urgent phones broke in: "Did you hear? Eleven dead in Gaza!
Eleven! We must do something!"
And the sickeningly familiar routine was on once
again: hasty consultations between peace groups, to determine place and time,
and then hours of phone calls, composing and sending of email action alerts and
press releases, placing of announcements on relevant websites and online forums,
drawing of signs and placards, and then off to downtown Tel-Aviv. (At some
moment during these hours the number of dead Gazans rose to twelve.)
And there we are - the activists of Gush Shalom which initiated the
action, and Anarchists Against Fences, and Women's Coalition for Peace, and
Hadash Young Communists, and the veteran Latif Dori of Meretz, and quite a few
people with no specific organizational allegiance. Altogether, some 120 people
turned up.
On the one side, the new Defence Ministry Tower
with the distinctive helicopter landing "saucer" on its roof - built at
considerable expanse and inaugurated in a festive ceremony last year. On the
other side, the Azrielli Twin Towers with their giant shopping mall, Tel Aviv's
pride, the very symbol and acme of the rich, uncaring, corporate Israel
which emerged in the past two decades. In between, the Begin Road, a major
artery through which thousands of cars speed at all hours, and us waving signs
and flags and banners and chanting in unison at the top of our voices and some
making wild hand gestures at the passing cars and pedestrians:
"Blockade -
NO! Ceasefire - YES!" - "No Tanks and No Qassams - Ceasefire Now!" - "End
the Bloodshed - Ceasefire Now!" - "The Blockade on Gaza is a War Crime!" - "End
the Economic Strangulation of Gaza!" - "There is No Military Solution in Gaza!"
- "Ceasefire in Gaza and Sderot!" - "Hamass Is a Partner for a Ceasefire!" - "I
Am a Gazan, Too!" - "In Gaza and Sderot, Children Want to Live!" - "Barak,
Barak, hey hey hey, How Many Kids Did You Kill Today?" - "Israel and Palestine,
Two States for Two Peoples!" - "Israel and Palestine, a Brotherhood of Peoples!"
- "All the Ministers are War Criminals" - "Ehud, Ehud, You Are Expected at the
Hague!" - "Ehud, Ehud, Both of You Are Expected at the Hague!" - "The Occupation
is a Disaster, Peace is the Solution!"
Two motorcycle riders who passed at great speed
tried to grab a Gush Shalom Two-States flag from a demonstrator. A few
minutes later, a young woman was rather dangerously leaning out of an open car
window to call "Good luck, I am with you!".
The police which appeared soon afterwards - one
patrol car, followed by another two - held short negotiations, and were
satisfied with the promise that we would go away after an hour. The parked
patrol cars actually created a traffic-free zone beside the pavement, in which
press and activist photographers could stand and take photos of the straggling
line of protesters. And the police did politely lead away the middle aged man
who shouted, his face contorted "Why are you allowing these traitors..."
Towards the end, a short dialogue with a bypassing
older couple:
The man:
What are you demonstrating about?
Activist: Did you not
hear? Eleven people killed today in Gaza.
The woman: Eleven? Of
ours?
Activist: We are the
ones to blame.
[A short silence.]
The
man: Yes, the government, but this will not
help.
Activist: Probably
not, but somebody has to start shouting.